When USA Today ran a piece last week, suggesting that Christians have misappropriated the Old Testament — the Hebrew Bible — for their views on abortion, I took notice.
What I found was an article that quoted the most liberal Jewish voices on these biblical issues while ignoring everyone else.
There is a range of rabbinical opinion on this issue, but you wouldn’t know it from this piece. That’s bad journalism.
The lead sentence begins with the assertion that the anti-abortion views of Christians are connected to their faith. Then:
This is a familiar argument for the Republican Party when it comes to abortion access. In January, Kirk Cox, speaker of the Virginia House of Delegates, cited biblical scripture when he came out against a proposed bill that would lift late-term abortion restrictions.
"You knit me together in my mother’s womb,” he said, quoting Psalm 139. “You watched me as I was being formed in utter seclusion as I was woven together in the dark of the womb. You saw me before I was born.”
But for many leaders in the Jewish faith, such interpretations are problematic and even insulting.
“It makes me apoplectic,” says Danya Ruttenberg, a Chicago-based rabbi who has written about Jews' interpretation of abortion. “Most of the proof texts that they’re bringing in for this are ridiculous. They’re using my sacred text to justify taking away my rights in a way that is just so calculated and craven.”
Like, how is this view of Psalm 139 “ridiculous”? It clearly states that the unborn child is a person knit together by God.
Also, if “many” Jewish leaders are offended by this kind of interpretation of a Psalm, which is true, the implication is that there are other points of view inside Judaism. Correct?