GetReligion.org - GetReligion » “The press . . . just doesn’t get religion.” — William Schneider
member of beliefnet's blogheaven

Recent Posts

Who’s offended? | When Lutherans split | All (Catholic) news is local (and modern) | Holy high holidays! | Teletubbies and … Islam? | Cutesy phrases aside | Westboro’s swing at anti-Semitism | ‘Road’ campaign markets apocalypse | Palin’s pastor meets the press | Catholics: racist, sexist and all wrong | 2009 Archive >


Saturday, August 4, 2007
Posted by dpulliam

The New York Times’ blog The Caucus reports on the juicy conflict between the presidential campaigns of former Arkansas governor Mike Huckabee and Sen. Sam Brownback that is steeped in religious issues and language.

This story has made the rounds in various formats, but this is the best coverage of the spat largely because reporter Sarah Wheaton took the time and effort to cut and paste large sections of the e-mails from the row.

It’s important that the story has not made the print edition, and I don’t think it needs to be there.

This is where news organizations’ blogs can shine. This isn’t front-page news by any measure. It’s two second-tier (or third) candidates squabbling over issues that don’t directly relate to a person’s qualifications for the presidency. But it is a fascinating battle between candidates who would attempt to inherit the mantle that President Bush carried in the 2000 campaign as the candidate of the Religious Right. So take a look at this:

A little e-mail battle brewing over the past few days between Senator Sam Brownback of Kansas and Mike Huckabee, the former governor of Arkansas, is escalating into an endless Punch-and-Judy show. And like spellbound children, we’re captivated by every volley.

It all started with an e-mail written by the Rev. Tim Rude, a Huckabee supporter, asking two Brownback supporters to consider switching sides. The longish e-mail contained some typical pitches, but there was also this:

Huckabee is an evangelical. He has not learned how to speak to evangelicals; i.e. Bush 41 & 43. He is one of us. I know Senator Brownback converted to Roman Catholicism in 2002. Frankly, as a recovering Catholic myself, that is all I need to know about his discernment when compared to the Governor’s. I don’t if this fact is widely known among evangelicals who are supporting Brownback. [sic.]

As they say, them’s fightin’ words.

One additional detail that I wish the NYT had included for context is what Noam Scheiber reported in The New Republic in December 2006 on Brownback’s conversion to Catholicism:

There are less flattering explanations as well. Brownback had always had a weakness for elite societies. He applied twice to be a White House Fellow before being admitted. When he got to Congress, Rolling Stone has reported, he sought admission to a small “cell” overseen by “The Fellowship,” an organization of evangelical elites. Catholicism in general, and McCloskey’s flock in particular, may have been just another upscale fraternity to pledge.

Nor is it easy to ignore how Brownback’s conversion has given him a beachhead in each of the two most powerful communities on the religious right. Even Congdon concedes there was some skepticism in the pews of TBC when news of the conversion made the rounds. “I fielded a lot of questions from suspicious people who thought that was just a political conversion,” he says.

I am not saying this is the reason Brownback converted — the article lists a more plausible reason just before these paragraphs — but it might help explain why the Huckabee supporter would bring up Brownback’s conversion as a political ax to grind.

There is also the aspect that the staffs of both candidates are using religious undertones to demean the other side. Here is Huckabee’s campaign manager Chip Saltsman, in response to the Brownback campaign’s response to an apology for the original e-mail, courtesy of the NYT:

It’s time for Sam Brownback to stop whining and start showing some of the Christian character he seems to always find lacking in others. He has attacked Governor Huckabee for something that a Huckabee supporter said in an email sent to two individuals. The person who originated the email has apologized and is not a member of the Huckabee staff. For Brownback to claim that the Governor “owes him an apology” is nonsense and indicates that if Brownback is going to fall to pieces every time a supporter of the Governor says something he doesn’t like, he clearly isn’t tough enough to be President. The Governor strongly disavowed the statement by the supporter, but that wasn’t enough for Brownback. He continued to cry about it. The irony is that unlike Senator Brownback, I have been a Catholic my entire life, as have several of the senior staff members in the Huckabee campaign. Governor Huckabee enjoys strong support from Catholics and for good cause. If Senator Brownback wants to start apologizing for inappropriate things said, perhaps he could pull the “beam out of his own eye before taking the speck out of someone else’s” by apologizing for the website ‘Baptists for Brownback’ that states that Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, Fred Thompson and others are ‘Hell bound.’

The battle goes on.

Perhaps it’s time to write the story that says that the two conservative evangelical candidates running in the 2008 Republican primary are close to writing themselves out of the race due to their silly snipping? Does this squabble show signs of serious cracks in the Religious Right, or is this just petty bickering that shows the immaturity of the two campaigns and the lack of adult supervision?

  • Share/Bookmark
Page Icon Posted at 9:49 am | Print Print | Permalink | Trackback | Comments (11)
divider

11 Responses to “Great reporting on a GOP kitten fight”

  1. Stephen A. says:

    The argument between these two Lilliputians is ridiculous. Neither of them have caught fire with the GOP voter (Brownback’s still in the race?) and their religion is of little concern to most - except perhaps to those who point out the extremism of both of these candidates.

    Huckabee is famous in Arkansas for calling “unChristian” all who disagreed with his plan to give (at taxpayer expense) illegal aliens the right to in-state tuition, and other goodies, and Brownback should apologize for his followers’ semi-official blog “Blogs4Brownback,” in which the extreme fundamentalism is almost laughable. (How about “Heliocentrism is an Atheist Doctrine”?)

    As for the coverage, I guess it “covers” religion, but I’m not entirely sure that this is what is meant, ideally, by “religion news,” and whether we learn anything about the religion or values of the principals here. I suppose noting, and exposing, a possible anti-Catholic trend in politics is helpful.

    However, this simply sounds like a bunch of low-level campaign staffers - and one manager - engaging in a “peeing” contest (cleaned up) who should have been reigned in about two emails ago by their respective campaign managers, or by the candidates themselves.

    Speaking as someone who has engaged in politics, this kind of exchange is unacceptable, frankly.

    I’d advise both of them to have a very public meeting, perhaps over lunch, and put this to bed. But knowing what we now know about these clowns, they’d probably start a fistfight over who got to say ‘grace.’

  2. Psycheout says:

    Stephen, why should Brownback apologize for us? What have we done except keep our readers informed about the latest Brownback buzz? We are not an official campaign blog, we are Blogs 4 Brownback, not Blogs of Brownback.

    We talk about issues other than politics, from time to time. Sisyphus, our science correspondent, likes to write about science topics. So what?

    We have a lot of readers who appreciate what we do.

  3. Psycheout says:

    And furthermore, I think we did some very respectable coverage of this whole Brownback/Huckabee brawl. I think you’d have to agree.

  4. dw says:

    Stephen, why should Brownback apologize for us?

    Wait, you’re real? The “Sissification of Seattle” post wasn’t a spoof?

    Wow, my day just got weird in a hurry.

  5. Psycheout says:

    dw, I’m not part of Baptists for Brownback. I’m a contributor to Blogs 4 Brownback.

    Hopefully you can discern the difference.

  6. dw says:

    Hopefully you can discern the difference.

    Yeah, I think I do. Baptists 4 Brownback is either far funnier or far scarier than you.

  7. Stephen A. says:

    “Sisyphus, our science correspondent…”

    That’s “science” in HUGE quotes, to qualify it from true science, which long ago established that the Earth is neither the center of the solar system nor the universe.

    And the lack of official sanction for that bizarre neo-Luddite blog has NEVER been made clear by the Brownback campaign. Unless you can point out where they’ve distanced themselves from you folks.

  8. Martha says:

    Stephen, if politicians weeded out all their weirdo supporters, there’d be about five people both eligible and interested in voting for them ;-)

    Having said that, neither of the two gentlemen has covered themselves in glory here. Yes, the original email was the idea all off his own bat of an over-enthusiastic campaigner, and yes, there were elements that needed to be disassociated from the candidate and his official position.

    But loudly demanding tea and sympathy on the one side, and equally loudly yelling about the mean things one of your friends said about my aunt Agatha on the other, just goes to demonstrate once again that a politician’s religion boils down to “Oh God, let me get elected!”

  9. Pink Raygun - News, Reviews and Interviews for Fangirls and Boys says:

    […] Candidates will bicker over their political track records, but Mike Huckabee and Sam Brownback are trying a different approach to discrediting one another in the public eye. They’re bickering about righteousness. […]

  10. Links for 2007-08-06 [del.icio.us] says:

    […] Great reporting on a GOP kitten fight » GetReligion […]

  11. Ft. Hard Knox » links for 2007-08-07 says:

    […] A GOP kitten fight “ Ar the two conservative evangelical candidates running in the 2008 Republican primary close to writing themselves out of the race due to their silly snipping? (tags: 2008 religion huckabee brownback) […]