GetReligion.org - GetReligion » “The press . . . just doesn’t get religion.” — William Schneider
member of beliefnet's blogheaven

Recent Posts

Church and the single life | Did the pope soften his stance on nuns? | Splitting the Catholic labels really fine | Old Catholics vs. the pope | Didn’t CNN fact check the holy popsicles? | Slow-pitch screamer on the Godbeat | In the end, Summer worked hard for her Lord | Same-sex marriage, celebration and “core values” | Has Time printed the worst Anglican article ever? | That Gray Lady Catholic same-sex unions scoop 2.0 | 2012 Archive >


Tuesday, May 10, 2011
Posted by Bobby Ross Jr.
Share

 

Tornado Alley. 

The Bible Belt. 

Do the two comprise the same general area or not?

Just a random question that entered my mind as I perused coverage of the April 27 tornadoes that killed hundreds and injured thousands in the South — and I don’t imagine that there is one right answer.

But I wondered about it when I read this Reuters headline:

In tornado-ravaged Bible Belt, churches mobilize to help

Anyway …

Last week, I highlighted coverage of faith and hope after the nation’s deadliest twister outbreak in decades. Now, nearly two weeks after the big storm, faith-based relief efforts are gaining media attention.

The Reuters story gave this breathless description of church relief workers:

These are not naive, disorganized do-gooders. They are professional volunteers with first class equipment and meticulous training.

Smelley’s crew maintains a trailer filled with chainsaws, safety glasses, chaps, gloves, extra chains and chainsaw repair tools. It is parked at a church member’s home for fast access. Similar trailers dot the parking lots of churches from nearly every religious denomination in Alabama.

Some trailers open out into “feeding units,” such as one maintained by the Baptist denomination that is a 53-foot semi-truck and can issue 25,000 meals a day.

Other units include a shower and laundry truck, emergency child-care trucks, supply trucks, and tool trucks like the chainsaw trailers, according to Keith Hinson, spokesperson for Baptist Disaster Relief. Several warehouses store the trailers packed with supplies and equipment.

The New York Times, similarly, sang the praises of Baptists:

Of course, thousands of church members are doing their part to help the South recover from the tornadoes. They raise money, sort clothing donations and hand out water.

They are what the veterans of large faith-based relief efforts call S.U.V.’s — spontaneous untrained volunteers. The efforts are welcomed, but they have nothing on what the Southern Baptists bring to a disaster.

From an elaborate “war room” in a church building in Montgomery, Ala., to direct lines of communication with federal and local emergency agencies, the Southern Baptist disaster ministry is a model of efficiency.

I promise. That’s from the Times, not Baptist Press.

I think it’s wonderful that major media are recognizing the crucial role that faith-based groups play in disaster relief and reporting on it. But I would prefer — please don’t hate me, Baptists — that a news story provide a source when characterizing an organization as a “model of efficiency.”

Then again, the Times includes attribution (general as it is) but not a lot of concrete evidence to back up this statement:

But when it comes to disaster relief, the link between church and state has never been stronger than during the most recent storms in the South, say federal officials and the leaders of faith-based disaster relief work.

Alas, this is the Times, so a story like this would not be complete without a section about (cue the dramatic music) “proselytizing victims”:

Religion and secular rescue efforts do not always mix easily. Jessica Powers, a Red Cross volunteer from New York who ran the feeding operation in conjunction with the Southern Baptist group here, said that on a disaster mission in Louisiana, a Baptist worker riding along with the Red Cross was proselytizing victims.

“I had to say to him that the Red Cross is a humanitarian organization, and one of our positions is neutrality,” she said.

For the Baptists, spreading the word about Jesus Christ is an essential reason they head into disaster zones over and over.

“You have an opportunity to tell people that the Lord loves you,” Mr. Blankenship said. “When you hand someone food when they’re hungry, the door’s open.

Meanwhile, The Associated Press did a story on churches of different denominations forging bonds after the tornadoes. It’s a laudable attempt at enterprise reporting, but it seemed to me that it tried to stretch a relatively weak anecdote into too large a story.

The AP report opened with a Baptist pastor leaving a voice mail at an Assemblies of God church. The Baptist pastor offered the Assemblies of God church — damaged in the storm — any help that it needed, including use of the Baptist building. Maybe it’s me, but that did not seem like a remarkable phone call. It impressed me as something many pastors of different denominations would do.

Later in the story, though, we find out that the Assemblies of God church did not accept the Baptist invitation:

Despite the offer from Watkins, Jacks moved his Assembly of God congregation of about 400 for a Thursday evening service to the non-denominational Peoples Church in nearby Hueytown, where he once served as worship leader and where the services are closer to his own Pentecostal denomination’s exuberant style of raised hands and singing and clapping.

Besides, the pastor, Buddy Poe, is an old friend who says God came to him and told him to open his door to Jacks and his congregation. Jacks says God delivered a similar message to him.

Besides? Am I the only one thinking those paragraphs out of order? Um, if God made a personal visit (“came to him”) to one pastor and “delivered a similar message” to the other, did that perhaps play a bigger role than the style of worship?

Alas, those are the only two sentences in the entire story about God’s role in where the congregation decided to meet. The AP drops that angle like a hot potato!

Finally, and I have saved the best for last, if you like a fantastic story told in a compelling way, you must read CNN’s piece on faith and football — and even the history of race relations — in tornado-ravaged Tuscaloosa, Ala.:

On April 27, a mile-wide tornado tore through Tuscaloosa, one of nearly 200 twisters to strike the South as part of a record storm. Hundreds died, including dozens in this college town – many of whom lived in the area known as Alberta City where College Hill Baptist sits.

The church lies at the center of the damage, as well as at the crossroads of faith, football and Alabama history. In a community where gospel and gridiron are interwoven like a hand-stitched Southern quilt, it all comes together at College Hill Baptist.

I’ll resist the urge to copy and paste giant sections of the 2,400-word story, but I will share my favorite graf of the entire piece:

A pious man with veins that bleed Crimson Tide and Bible scripture, Greene says the tornado looked like the devil when it came through. “It began to make a tail,” he says in an accent as thick as sorghum. “It went up in the air, like it had arms and shoulders.”

Read the whole thing. It almost made this Sooner fan (and resident of Tornado Alley/the Bible Belt) want to scream, “Roll Tide!” But not quite.

Page Icon Posted at 1:29 pm | Print Print | Permalink | Trackback | Comments (13)
divider

13 Responses to “Religion angles twist in Tornado Alley”

  1. Will says:

    I would say the Times story makes the point that one man’s “proselytizing” is another’s charity or free speech.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  2. Jerry says:

    Unfortunately I won’t be clicking on the NY Times story because of their limit on free stories.

    But in general, for stories that claim “proselytizing”, I want to know specifically what people are doing? Are they, for example, wearing a T-Shirt that says “God loves you”? Are they, when asked, saying that they are there because Jesus teaches that we should help our bothers and sisters who are in need? Does what they are handing out mention God or Jesus? In other words, given how charged the word proselytizing has become, I really want specifics about what is meant by that word in the particular case.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

  3. bob smietana says:

    True confession— until moving to the South I had no idea how much disaster relief work the Baptists do. And how closely denominations and groups like the Red Cross work together.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  4. Dave says:

    It’s hardly surprising that Tornado Alley and the Bible Belt coincide in places. People just don’t live in that kind of environment without some sacralization of what’s happening to them. I would expect MSM reporters from the area to be able to handle this aspect, but not so the ones from out of town.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  5. Ray Ingles says:

    Alas, this is the Times, so a story like this would not be complete without a section about (cue the dramatic music) “proselytizing victims”

    Um… why “alas”? Is this not a newsworthy factor? If not, why not?

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

  6. Harold says:

    I’m going to be a cynic here and argue that CNN story was really a trope-filled parade of cliches. The God and Football storyline is easy. It doesn’t take any work to be that manipulative. I was struck by Bobby’s acknowledgment that when he was at the AP, there was sort of a canned weather crisis story that involved attending church on Sunday and reporting on the sermons. I realize journalists need formulas, but doesn’t that just lead us to cliches (and a bit of condsecension?)

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  7. Brett says:

    A pious man with veins that bleed Crimson Tide and Bible scripture, Greene says the tornado looked like the devil when it came through. “It began to make a tail,” he says in an accent as thick as sorghum. “It went up in the air, like it had arms and shoulders.”

    What truly awful writing. If it were fiction, I would suggest Mr. Drash consider submitting this to the Bulwer-Lytton competition.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  8. Harold says:

    What truly awful writing. If it were fiction, I would suggest Mr. Drash consider submitting this to the Bulwer-Lytton competition.

    Can I hear an Amen?

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  9. David Edmisten says:

    The mainstream media reporting always seems to find the negative twist, don’t they? I think it is a fantastic statement of the love of Christ exercised through the work of the church to see so many volunteering their time, money, energy and resources to help the victims. How about just being glad that Christ’s followers are willing and ready to step out when help is needed?

    Also, the media seems to have such a negative focus on sharing faith in the midst of help. Sharing love and hope in a time of crisis is a loving act. Perhaps when skeptics finally read the truth of what the Bible teaches, they will learn that most Christians are just sharing truth, not seeking converts.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 2

  10. Dave says:

    David Edmiston takes me back to the California quake of the 1980s. I kept the radio on because I have family in San Francisco. Two reports from the field popped up during the evening: one of looting, and one of volunteers helping direct traffic as the signals were out.

    As the night wore on the reporters of course repeated themselves constantly. The looting report got embedded in their cycle of memes. The traffic report got dropped out.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  11. Larry says:

    The CNN story was well done! but you can’t expect quality everywhere.

    What’s important is that folks in Tornado country know there nothing men can do to prevent a tornado coming through, except count you blessing and pray you could’ve afford a basement. Ironic the Bible Belt runs hard through the Bible Belt and thank god for the charitable people there to help so many that were affected by these storms. It seems like Tornado Alley is shifting southward from the upper Mississippi and plains traditional associated with it, and maybe the Bible Belt is shifting up the Mississippi, too. Either way there’s nothing we can do to prevent tornadoes. At the same time the Diabetes Belt corresponds directly to the Bible Belt and there is things we can do to prevent it. Diabetes easily kills as many people as tornadoes, probably more but the impact is spread out.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 2

  12. Bill P. says:

    On a related topic, which I blogged about after the killer tornadoes in the Southeast: has anyone caught any post-event interviews with tornado chasers who were recording and following these beasts? I wonder what they thought and how they changed after learning of the unrelenting damage and the loss of life that these storms brought to so many.

    Tornado chasers—especially commercial ones—seem to enjoy themselves with the hunt and scurrying about in hail. (And I can understand why. I’ve always wanted to do this.) But have any of these folks had a change of heart? Has any asked for forgiveness for seeking profit or pleasure in other people’s pain? Inquiring minds want to know.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  13. Bobby says:

    Um… why “alas”? Is this not a newsworthy factor? If not, why not?

    Ray, sorry to be AWOL. Been away from the computer the last couple of days.

    I think it is a newsworthy factor, but I think it could have been handled in a less predictable way. Why not take the two paragraphs about this being how Baptists express their faith and put them ahead of the “proselytizing victims” paragraphs? Maybe that doesn’t change the tone, but I think it would have helped. Or maybe not …

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0